Monday, June 30, 2008

Weight for it...

Should the Islanders sign Doug Weight to a one-year deal this week or next, there will be an audible groan out of large districts within Islanders Country.

(Cripes, I sound like Stan Fischler with that one. Let me try again).

The Islanders are going to sign Doug Weight sometime in the next two weeks and the initial reaction will likely be unfavorable. People will point to Doug’s 37 years and 1,137 regular season NHL games and rightfully declare the last thing the Islanders’ youth movement needed was a smallish center near the end of his career. There will be plenty of jokes worthy of the Catskills: “This is a good signing…in 1998”!

For one year at a fair price, signing Doug Weight is a smart move.

There’s no way around it. The Islanders need centers. They have Mike Comrie, who needs someone to be his co-No. 2 . They have Mike Sillinger, coming off major hip surgery at age 37. Richard Park can play center, but seems to have found a niche with the Islanders as a wing. They have prospect Frans Nielsen, who can be an outstanding NHLer with the proper development and patient coaching. There’s Ben Walter for depth and not much else for now.

Why move a terrific young player like Blake Comeau to center if you don’t have to?

In 2005-06, Weight was instrumental in leading the Carolina Hurricanes to the Stanley Cup. The year after he was 16-43-59 with St. Louis (would you not sign up for that right now?). Last year he bounced from the Blues to the Ducks and never got on track.

It would be completely unfair to say he is done just because he’s 37.

There aren’t many great options for the Islanders at center in the UFA market that opens tomorrow. Doug Weight will play hard, lead, teach, settle down the power play, get at least 40 points and represent the Islanders well.

4 comments:

Chris said...

I dont htink this would be a bad thing, actually.
But then again, I dont think that bringing Vasichek back would have been that bad, either.

If he and Guerin like playing together and they think they can still cut it, fine- great. At least the guys is a center!

So the Islanders will be a bunch of kiddies, and a number of 37yo's... and Comrie and Rick. lmao.

Exposing Islam said...

I think it would be a wise move.

B.D. Gallof said...

37 is just getting to the spice of life!

BD
(will be 38 in two months)

Justin Marques said...

I think signing Weight would be a very good idea. Bailey needs another year at the minimum before he even dares to crack an NHL lineup, and Weight is a perfect one year fill in for the Islanders. We need a center desperately, and he can teach the kids a lot, while also being able to play sound offensive and defensive hockey. If we reach the deadline and no longer have a shot at the playoffs, he can certainly be used as an asset to acquire another draft pick at the least. My only fear is that the Isles might try and bring back Bertuzzi and say they wanted a top six forward...hopefully it doesn't happen.